Mount Kisco protesters yield ground to holiday creche and menorah
By MARTIN WILBUR
The weekly Saturday protesters outside Mount Kisco Village Hall have agreed to move their rallies next month so they don’t interfere with or obstruct the creche and menorah that will be displayed outside the library.
During Monday’s Village Board meeting, Mayor J. Michael Cindrich said three local synagogues, the Knights of Columbus, the Chamber of Commerce and the village had asked that the demonstrators relocate for the holiday season. He consulted Village Manager Ed Brancati and Village Attorney Jonathan Nelson before formally making the request to be certain it complied with the law.
Cindrich said the entities responsible for the creche and the menorah outside the library received their permits and submitted insurance certificates and would like the public to view them without interference. The village’s Christmas tree will also be nearby.

“The people doing this expect people to walk up to the creche, and even though the protesters are only there an hour or two — I don’t know how long they’re there — but they expect the visibility,” Cindrich said. “They filed insurance certificates and they should have the right that we bestowed on other people.”
Initially, the mayor asked that the organizers of the Rally for Democracy either move in front of Village Hall or another area on Dec. 12, 19 and 26. It could also include Dec. 5. The local Knights of Columbus did not specify in its permit request to the village when the creche would begin being displayed. The Christmas tree lighting is on Dec. 4 and the menorah lighting ceremony is on Dec. 6, although the first night of Hanukkah is two nights earlier.
“What we’re doing is acknowledging that we’re supporting permits for these edifices to be installed, not for their personal satisfaction, but for the public and people with children to walk by like I did with my kids to explain to them what a menorah is, and obviously they knew from when they were 5 years old, they knew what a creche was,” Cindrich said. “I think this is an important thing and I think it’s an important thing for the unity of this community during these difficult times.”
Asking the protesters to move does not run afoul of the First Amendment, according to Nelson. He said if there were any issues, he would consult with Brancati.
One of the organizers of the rally, Marianne Delaney, said she and co-organizer Fred Silverman would comply with the village’s request. Since shifting the protests from Kisco Avenue to outside Village Hall and the library in the summer of 2025, they have also moved the gatherings to Green Street and Lexington Avenue when conflicts have arisen. Typically, the rally starts at about 12:30 or 1 p.m. on Saturday afternoons and continues to about 2 p.m.
“We certainly would want to definitely cooperate with what you’re saying and show absolute respect for both the menorah and the creche,” Delaney said. “So we will work to make sure that happens.”
In recent months, the protests have been a flashpoint for some residents who find the demonstrators’ political signs, chants and amplified music disruptive, and some have claimed they block the sidewalk and the library entrance. The protests have been held every weekend since shortly after President Donald Trump’s second inauguration.


.png)


![CA-Recorder-Mobile-CR-2025[54].jpg](https://static.wixstatic.com/media/09587f_b989949ec9bc46d8b6ea89ecc2418a8a~mv2.jpg/v1/fill/w_370,h_150,al_c,q_80,enc_avif,quality_auto/CA-Recorder-Mobile-CR-2025%5B54%5D.jpg)




