Lewisboro Planning Board discusses plan for Reynolds property
By NEAL RENTZ
The Lewisboro Planning Board on Nov. 17 discussed the possible plan to rezone a parcel in Cross River for a senior housing development.
The discussion was about a concept introduced to the Town Board on Nov. 9 from 831 Route 35 Cross River LLC for 90 senior housing units on the historic Reynolds property.
A rendering, but no formal application, was provided to the Town Board earlier this month. The senior housing proposal was unanimously opposed by residents who spoke at the recent Town Board meeting, and Town Board members expressed skepticism about the idea.

A previous proposal from 831 Route 35 Cross River LLC was to divide the 14.5-acre property into lots of between 0.5 and 1.1 acres for a 14-lot subdivision. That 14-home plan was sharply criticized by residents earlier this year at a Town Board meeting, and a petition drive gathered hundreds of signatures in opposition.
The subdivision proposal was last before the Planning Board in July. Planning Board Chair Janet Andersen said at the Nov. 9 Town Board meeting that the developer had presented a preliminary site plan to her board earlier this year.
Counsel to the Planning Board Judson Siebert this week laid out the process for changing the zoning at 831 Route 35 from residential to a Senior Housing Floating Zone.
The zone would require Town Board approval, Andersen said.
“It’s entirely discretionary for the Town Board to decide whether to even entertain it,” Siebert said. “Typically, when this type of situation is presented, that petition is not presented in a vacuum.”
Among the issues the Planning Board would review if the zoning change is made are the housing project’s effects on traffic, lighting and the environment, Siebert said.
Siebert said an applicant would also prepare “a definite, concrete proposal” for the potentially rezoned property.
If the rezoning were approved by the Town Board, site plan and special permit approvals from the Planning Board would be needed for the project to go forward, Siebert said. The site plan and special permit applications would be filed “in tandem” with the petition to the Town Board for the zoning change, he said.
“The two processes sort of begin to move in tandem,” he said.
In response to a question from Planning Board member Charlene Indelicato, Siebert said he believed the Planning Board would be designated as lead agency for the senior housing project review. The Town Board “recognizes the skills that are practiced here by virtue of having done other SEQR reviews,” Andersen said. “That’s not a common thing for them.”
For the zoning change to go forward, certain criteria would need to be met, Siebert said.
“It’s not spot zoning,” he said.


.png)


![CA-Recorder-Mobile-CR-2025[54].jpg](https://static.wixstatic.com/media/09587f_b989949ec9bc46d8b6ea89ecc2418a8a~mv2.jpg/v1/fill/w_370,h_150,al_c,q_80,enc_avif,quality_auto/CA-Recorder-Mobile-CR-2025%5B54%5D.jpg)




