Pound Ridge eyes home for new police headquarters

By THANE GRAUEL
The Pound Ridge Town Board’s surprise announcement that it is seeking to buy a $1.67 million house adjacent to the Town Park to house its Police Department drew a large crowd to Tuesday night’s meeting.
An actual purchase of 205 Westchester Ave., a 3,450-square-foot cabin-style house next to the park’s entrance, was not on the agenda, but motions to accept an appraisal of the property and seek designation as the lead agency for a SEQRA environmental review were.
Both motions passed unanimously, but not before a range of opinions on the plan was voiced by speakers. Some were in support of the plan, many had concerns and just about everyone said that whatever their opinion, they supported the police in general.

The last public discussion of a police headquarters was in the summer of 2025, when the Town Board reviewed an architect’s report on rebuilding the existing 1,000-square-foot structure on the Town House campus. That structure is said to be too small and outdated for the current needs of the department, according to local officials. Building a new headquarters at the current site would have cost between $4.8 million and $5 million.
“That’s a little strong,” Town Supervisor Kevin Hansan said of the price tag Tuesday.
“Then subsequently we were approached about 205 (Westchester Ave.) becoming available on the market, and that property is right next to the Town Park, for those of you that aren’t familiar with it,” he said.
Hansan announced the plan to purchase the Westchester Avenue property to house the Police Department in his weekly newsletter last Friday, Nov. 13.
John McCown said the purchase would affect taxes beyond the purchase cost by changing the equalization rate.
“It’s incumbent on the town to perform its own detailed analysis,” he said. “The town should disclose its analysis and the effect it sees on property tax payments by residents in all years going forward. That analysis should be done before any decision is made on this purchase.”
Time to evaluate
Joseph Virgilio, who lives next door to the house being eyed by the town, was concerned about how local officials disclosed the plan.
“Because this packet only came out Friday afternoon, ahead of tonight’s meeting, residents have had very little time to digest it,” he said of the meeting materials posted on the town’s website. “Under New York’s Open Meetings Law,” he continued, “executive sessions for real estate are strictly limited to protecting the purchase price during negotiation, not shielding a major municipal relocation from the public.”
“How does rushing a major land use change on a compressed holiday timeline align with the transparency and public trust required by Pound Ridge’s code?” Virgilio asked.
Nick Cianciola Sr. wondered if the purchase fit into a larger plan to eventually put a wastewater treatment plant on the Old Pound Road parcel.
“It gives you the ability to have a wastewater treatment plant,” he said. “I don’t know from an environmental perspective, but a wastewater treatment plant here (could) pump water down to Scotts Corners. So, is this in the back of your mind?”
“Now, you don’t have to answer any questions, because this is a discussion, it’s not like public comment,” Cianciola said. “But I’m putting this on record — that is what this is about.”
Sarah Sprung liked the idea of the Police Department being next to the Town Park.
“I actually think it’s a brilliant idea,” she said. “That’s a place where people are always speeding. You have all the children there for the camp, having the police there, to me, I don’t live there, but for everyone else …” she looked at Virgilio and continued, “I’m so sorry.”
That drew a laugh from the room.
“Obviously, I think it’s really important for our police to have a good place,” she said. “It’s been years that they’ve been living in this teeny tiny closet. I think it’s embarrassing. I’m surprised we’ve let it go this long.”
Worried about neighbors
Cheryl Schacht said she knows the current station is small and probably needs to be expanded, but worried about neighbors.
“People that have lived here so long,” she said. “They’re going to have to put up with all this construction and noise in front of their house — that really bothers me.”
She wondered if the present campus couldn’t still be used without spending $5 million, and how much the town might really save by moving the department if renovation costs weren’t yet known. She also wondered how purchasing a new property fit into long-term plans around the park and the Old Pound Road parcel.
“It would be nice if it was shared, so we kind of knew as taxpayers and residents what the plan is and where you guys are coming from,” she said.
John Nathan took issue with how the plan was disclosed.
“Those who follow my activities in this Town House know I am very big on process,” said Nathan, who has an appeal pending in an open-meeting lawsuit against the town for its handling of allowing cannabis sales in Pound Ridge.
“And what has happened here is that Friday night, we got what lawyers call ‘sewer service’ of this notice,” he said, a reference to improper service of court papers on a defendant in a lawsuit. “Nobody told us about this. The Town Board has known about this for seven weeks.”
“How do I know that?” he said. “Because it went into executive session on Oct. 6.”
And, he noted, “the appraisal was Oct. 28.”
“I’ve been very concerned about the Town Board, time and time again, doing things behind the scenes, right, with no notice or inadequate notice,” Nathan said. “And here it is, happening again.”
He promised, once the board passes a resolution to buy the property, to circulate a petition to force a permissive referendum, which would give the town’s voters the choice of whether to buy it.
Jill Faber, speaking via Zoom, said the town had given proper notice.
“I think we should not assume that the motives are not as they’re indicated,” she said. “And enough grandstanding.”
Board member Dan Paschkes defended the process.
“We have an opportunity to acquire something. We negotiated in order to not get into a bidding war with others, which would have raised the price, and made it more difficult,” he said. “And if we were to not lock in a contract, a contingent contract, but a contract that gives us the option to move forward, we lose the opportunity.”
Addressing Nathan, he said, “If you’re going to insist on trying to put a petition out on this, I would hope not. It’ll only raise costs to the town. It’ll only complicate the process if you try to do that.”
What about other costs?
Kevin New, another Westchester Avenue neighbor of the possible police station site, also wondered about a referendum and overall costs of moving.
“How can we say, with a straight face, that this is going to be such a financial bargain to the town when we have no idea what the renovation costs are going to be?” he asked.
Town Attorney William Harrington explained the referendum process, but said, “Right now, there is no contract.”
“This is just the beginning of the process,” he said.
Hansan said the purchase would be discussed again at the next Town Board meeting.
“Just so you know, there’s going to be three Town Board meetings scheduled in December to make this work,” Hansan said. They are Dec. 1, 15 and 18.


.png)


![CA-Recorder-Mobile-CR-2025[54].jpg](https://static.wixstatic.com/media/09587f_b989949ec9bc46d8b6ea89ecc2418a8a~mv2.jpg/v1/fill/w_370,h_150,al_c,q_80,enc_avif,quality_auto/CA-Recorder-Mobile-CR-2025%5B54%5D.jpg)




